User talk:Undouble

From Guild Wars 2 Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search

"Recovered" Charr Artifact/Drop rate[edit]

Several other users have also documented their drops from "Recovered" Charr Artifact at "Recovered" Charr Artifact/Drop rate and for all of them the total number is equal to the number of legion keys (summing up all four different types). I might be wrong because of the small sample, but based on the drop rate I assume that there is exactly one legion key in every artifact.

However, so far, you have added two drop with a lower number of keys than the total amount, namely:

{{"Recovered" Charr Artifact research line
 | Total = 2
 | Piece of Rare Unidentified Gear = 02 | Blood Legion Key = 01 | Legionnaire Staff#item4 = 01
 | user = Anonymous
 | timestamp = 02:29, 04 October 2019 (UTC)
}}

{{"Recovered" Charr Artifact research line
 | Total = 01
 | Piece of Rare Unidentified Gear = 01 | Flame Rifle#item7 = 01
 | user = Anonymous
 | timestamp = 18:17, 07 October 2019 (UTC)
}}

So two possiblities: either my assumption is wrong, well then everything is fine or your drop rate entries are incomplete. Hence, if possible may I ask you to check them again? --Tolkyria (talk) 18:33, 7 October 2019 (UTC)

For completion, including also your missing drop rate entry:
{{"Recovered" Charr Artifact research line
 | Total = 01
 | Piece of Rare Unidentified Gear = 01 | Flame Legion Key = 01 | Legionnaire Shield#item4 = 01
 | user = Anonymous
 | timestamp = 16:23, 07 October 2019 (UTC)
}}
The problem is that excluding your drop rate entries the legion key drop rate is 100%, namely 26 out of 26; while you have 2 keys out of 4 artifacts, i.e. 50% drop rate, that sounds really supicious.
Furthermore, Game updates/2019-10-01#Items states the following: ""Recovered" Charr Artifacts now have increased rewards: an additional piece of charr-themed gear, one of the four legion keys, and double the chance of receiving a Visage of the Khan-Ur." which can be interpreted as an guaranteed legion key drop. See also Talk:"Recovered" Charr Artifact#Oct 3 2019 note, I'm not the only one that reads it this way. Edit: typo --Tolkyria (talk) 20:47, 7 October 2019 (UTC)
I want to let you know that sample size increased to 40+ and excluding your entries still provides a 100% drop rate. Therefore I removed your, in my eyes incorrect, two drop rate entries, see also Talk:"Recovered" Charr Artifact/Drop rate#Clarification. --Tolkyria (talk) 08:36, 8 October 2019 (UTC)