Talk:Guild Claiming

Feedback 2020/07/22

There are significant errors and omissions on this page:

1. Public Tactic Activation is checked by default. Action is taken to disable, not enable, public use of tactics.
2. If you disable public activation, it will be re-enabled once all members of the claiming guild have left the map. (There was/may still be a bug where it resets when ANY member of a claiming guild leaves the map)
3. It is not clearly stated here that the claiming guild can replace any upgrade on the objective they own once it is ready. (Not on cooldown from slotting or using).
4. There is no way to drop claim other than to claim something else.
5. If a claim is swapped and a new claim made, the timers for each tier to slot upgrades restart. (e.g. you would have to wait 60 minutes to slot or swap a T3 upgrade)
6. Upgrades do not require supply anymore.
7. Tactics have either 20 or 30 minute cooldowns (not 15-20).
8. May be worth mentioning that cross-server guilds can still only claim 1 objective per map regardless of color.
9. The "Building," "Activation," and "Timing and Tiers" sections contain outdated, inaccurate, redundant, and confusing information. In addition to what's already been mentioned, the Timing and Tiers section incorrectly states that camps only have 2 tiers (they have 3), and the tiering-up process is controlled by successful dolyak transits, not time, and thus is highly variable.
10. The "Strategy" section is largely irrelevant to the page topic, refers specifically to the Desert map, and contains mostly unsourced and outdated opinions rather than game facts.
11. The "bug" note is no longer an issue.
—The preceding unsigned comment was added by 24.136.14.2 (talk) at 14:11, 22 July 2020‎ (UTC).

Excellent feedback, our WvW articles need some love.

1. Edited.
2. Added.
3. Added.
4. Acknowledge this is true but seems implied by "These enhancements remain if a guild changes the objective claimed in a zone (only one objective at a time may be claimed in each zone)"
5. Added.
6. Deleted bunch of sentences about supply from the Building section.
7. Amended to 20 or 30.
8. Added.
9. Reworded some of the three sections. Not sure if I got everything
10. Deleted the entire section, looked of dubious quality.
11. Bug note deleted.

I get the feeling the whole article could be rewritten from the top. -Chieftain Alex 17:52, 22 July 2020 (UTC)