Talk:First Foods Crafted

Example in the Notes is "Loaf of Bread" - probably should change that as I made Loaf of Bread and it didn't count for the achievement. I didn't make it because of this page but someone might. I came to this page looking for why my Loaf of Bread didn't count and what I SHOULD make. I'll update this note with my results but apparently every low level recipe does not count.

Update: You get a bunch of very basic "recipes" when you first learn Cooking. Only the first thing you make from those counts toward the achievement and it has to be food. I tried unidentified dye first but that did not count. After that first item that counted for the achievement, I made 1 of every other food item that I already knew and they did not count for the achievement.

2nd Update: Apparently crafted food 2-4 do not trigger the achievement but still do count. However I crafted more than 5 of the base food recipes that you automatically learn when you learn Cooking. I checked if the Master Chef sold any recipes I should try but they do not. So I tried Discovering a Recipe and that finished out the entire achievement. I chose Grilled Mushrooms but I'm guessing any of the low level Discovered recipes will do.

TLDR: Any of the FOOD recipes that you automatically learn with Cooking will count toward "Crafted Food 1-4" for the achievement but you won't "ding" "Crafted Food #5" until you discover a food.--Justaplayer (talk) 12:20, 9 July 2021 (UTC)